June 2012
33 posts
There is a corner of my brain marked 221B Baker Towers that is clamouring for some sort of deconstruction of the HUGE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM that is the fact that, in Sherlock, Moriarty is an evil Irish bomber.
Unfortunately, my brain feels like runny, PMS-y cheese right now,…
But his name is recognisably, stereotypically Irish! Especially in Britain.Conan-Doyle would have known that obviously.
I’ve been mulling this one over for a while now.
Just for a second, lets dismiss the mad bomber plot line, and just focus on Moriarty as a character overall.
Andrew Scott plays him as unmistakably Irish, but not some spud munching hurler from Offaly. He’s a weedy, effeminate man, with a posh D4 accent. He’s intelligent and well read, but in a way that suggests it was his birthright, not someone who read bewks by the light of a turf fire. He was destined to be a Trinners boy before he was even born.
I’ve watched a lot of movies that feature the IRA in some way for this project, and they’re all presented in much the same way. The movie may not agree with their morality, but they at least believe in something. They view their actions as the lesser of two evils, but they’re still tortured by the deaths they’ve caused. They’ve almost certainly been lead astray, and if only they chose a different route in life they could have done great things. There’s usually a strong Mystical Negro vibe with them as well, especially if they’re made by Americans.
Moriarty is none of those things. He enjoys killing people. He has no reason to do what he does, other than winding Sherlock Holmes up. He offers no justification for his actions, other than it tends to get peoples attention pretty quickly.
I’m still confused about my feelings on the matter. But, if you look at him in very narrow terms, as just a person with an Irish accent who blows things up in one of his two main stories, then yeah, he’s Oirish as hell. But if you look at him as a whole, and compare him to your typical Irish character, then he’s pretty much the exact opposite of everything we’ve ever had before. Even if you compare him to Bernard Black, an Irish character written and played by an Irishman, he still comes out less Oirish overall.
Solemn Novena - Juliette
Gothic Rock/Female Vocal, Ireland
- DJ Barry T:
- wow shit it's nearly one
- time for breakfast!
- Fly-Leen Grey:
- Haha
- If it helps
- I'm being grown up and mature
- And saving last nights pizza for dinner tonight
- Instead of breakfast
- Hahaha
- DJ Barry T:
- but pizza is the best breakfast!
- Fly-leen Grey:
- Yeah
- Maturity sucks [: (]
- DJ Barry T:
- yep [: (]
danceswithfaeriesunderthemooon:
need this on my blog again because of reasons.
Not strictly Irish, but always worth repeating.
- Captain B-Boycott:
- I watched Neon Genesis Evangelion there a little while back, it was pretty good
- if kind of depressing
- and confusing
- Tiocfaidh D:
- I watched the whole thing in one sitting one night
- That was ... odd
- Especially as it got REALLY weird right around the time sleep deprivation kicked in
- Captain B-Boycott:
- hahahaha yeah I'm not sure how much of a difference that would make
- I did like that essentially a major sub-theme is taking Christian imagery and ideas and completely divorcing them of all context and just using them to make everything seem cool and mystical. They sure got us back!
- Tiocfaidh D:
- OMG!
- THAT'S SO RACIST!
- AND OPPRESSING ME!
- QUICK!
- CALL TUMBLR!
Oscar Wilde’s rebuttal of charity and philanthropy. (via arvintumbles)
The Soul of Man Under Socialism is definitely Wilde’s best work. He’s not just all about obsessing over the ruling class, smutty jokes and intellectualising. There’s some good stuff in ol’ Oscar’s work.
(via ellentansey)
But mostly the smutty jokes …
White privilege is being the #1 consumers of welfare, food stamps, general government aid, and illegal drugs, but STILL blaming POC for all of those things as well as incarcerating them at an exponentially higher rate.
I feel like ‘this is white privelege’ comments like these ignore the class, cultural and socio-political contexts of pretty much everything ever, as well as the contextuality of race in and of itself.
And it’s completely Amerocentric.
White privilege is getting to derail a conversation on race by insisting that class is the most important intersection. When in reality, race is the biggest deciding factor in your class, and the biggest hindrance to your social mobility.
I’ll agree, a lot of tumblr can be pretty Amerocentric, but the general overview holds up most places.
Lets look at Britain, a place with a decent mixture of colours and creeds, and also one I’m personally familiar with. It also runs on different concepts of race and class. Whiteness isn’t homogenised, like it is America, and there are far more distinctions in the British Class system. Kate Middleton is considered common, but Fergie’s still posh.
My first job in London was in a bar, which just so happened to be owned by a really rich bloke from D4. So there was me, a Middle Class lass from the Pale, a rough as fuck handyman from Ballyfermot, and a grand auld Cark bai on the bar. Didn’t matter a jot to the English, we were all just seen as Irish. Regardless of how class worked between us in our day to day interactions, we were all on the same plane to outsiders. Class didn’t matter.
And yes, the British media is far more vocal about its hatred of the Working Class than they are in America. But if you’ll notice, it wasn’t chavs who were rioting last year, it was Black communities. Brixton, Hackney, Tottenham and Dalston are all poor areas, but they’re specifically poor Black areas. Shoreditch is just as poor, but also predominantly Asian, and saw comparatively little action.
Yes, the dynamics are different between Caribbean and African communities over here, and there are differences between how immigrants and children of immigrants in those communities are perceived. And these all interact with each other to varying degrees. But at the end of the day, the riots were sparked by the Police harassing Black people, irregardless of culture, ethnicity or accent. The overarching factor is race, not class or culture.
Even if we go to a comparatively white washed country as Ireland, class still doesn’t play as big a role as you’re trying to make out. The entire reason for the IRA split in 1969 was because of the Old IRAs refusal to protect Catholic communities, opting instead to try and unite the Working Class as a whole, despite Catholic communities facing the brunt of police, job and housing discrimination.
- Captain B-Boycott:
- oh shit
- ok
- don't get your hopes up
- but I think
- I just found Michael Fassbender reading Dracula